$10 Flat Rate Shipping On All Orders!

$10 Flat Rate Shipping On All Orders!

Your cart

Your cart is empty

Baby Gifts

A unique collection of baby gifts for those newborns entering the world.

103 Results

Mayoral Newborn Booties in Pink

Mayoral Newborn Booties in Pink

$ 28.99

Unit price
per 

Mayoral Newborn Booties

Mayoral Newborn Booties

$ 28.99

Unit price
per 

2 sizes
  • OM
  • 3M
Mayoral Newborn Mary Janes in Gold

Mayoral Newborn Mary Janes in Gold

$ 28.99

Unit price
per 

Mayoral Newborn Mary Janes

Mayoral Newborn Mary Janes

$ 28.99

Unit price
per 

Copper Pearl Alder Swaddle Blanket

Copper Pearl Alder Swaddle Blanket

$ 27.99

Unit price
per 

Floral Fancy Plush Dolls

Floral Fancy Plush Dolls

$ 24.99

Unit price
per 

Donkey Plushie

Donkey Plushie

$ 32.99

Unit price
per 

Mud Pie Merry Mischief 4 in 1 Puzzle Set

Mud Pie Merry Mischief 4 in 1 Puzzle Set

$ 15.99

Unit price
per 

A plush reindeer puppet book with a brown body, white and brown antlers, and a red nose. The book is designed with a fabric that resembles a Christmas themed snacks bag.

Mud Pie Reindeer Snacks Puppet Book

$ 26.99

Unit price
per 

A soft minky puppet book featuring a Santa Claus design with a red hat and white beard, a green Christmas tree, and a reindeer. The set includes a book with a story and matching pieces for interactive play.
A soft minky puppet book featuring a Santa Claus design with a red hat and white beard, a green Christmas tree, and a reindeer. The set includes a book with a story and matching pieces for interactive play.

Mud Pie Puppet Book

$ 26.99

Unit price
per 

A pink ruffled bow on a skinny nylon headband, designed for newborn babies.
A pink ruffled bow on a skinny nylon headband, designed for newborn babies.

Infants: In Awe Mini Headbands

$ 11.00

Unit price
per 

9 colors
  • +4 more
Wooden Christmas activity board featuring a Santa snack tray with wooden cookies, candy cane, gingerbread man, carrots, milk bottle, and reindeer treat bag, plus a plate for Santa’s cookies, a toy marker, and a chalkboard-style “Dear Santa” note with naughty and nice checkboxes.

Mud Pie Santa Snack Time Puzzle

$ 34.99

Unit price
per 

A set of four wooden puzzle pieces with Christmas themes, including an illustration of Santa, a gingerbread house,  a reindeer, and a Christmas tree.

Mud Pie Christmas 4-in-1 Puzzle Set

$ 15.99

Unit price
per